In 'Captain America: Brave New World,' Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson steps into the iconic role of Captain America, grappling with the legacy of his predecessor, Steve Rogers. The film explores Wilson's self-doubt and the pressure of living up to Rogers' legacy, but critics argue that these themes are handled with little depth. As Vulture notes, the film "pays lip service to Sam’s anxieties, but does little to explore or dramatize them" [1]. Despite Mackie's commendable performance, the script fails to provide a compelling narrative, leaving audiences wanting more from the character's development.

The film attempts to emulate the success of past Marvel political thrillers like 'Captain America: The Winter Soldier,' but critics argue it lacks the necessary intrigue and suspense. According to Men's Health, 'Brave New World' is "a conspiracy thriller with no one to be suspicious of," and fails to establish a gripping narrative [2]. The plot revolves around a global treaty and an assassination attempt, but the execution is described as sloppy and predictable, with key plot twists already revealed in the film's marketing.

While 'Brave New World' features some effective stunt work and action sequences, the overall visual presentation has been criticized for being lifeless and uninspired. ScreenCrush describes the film as 'inconsistent,' with some hand-to-hand combat scenes shining, while other visual effects appear clunky [3]. The film's attempt to balance superhero action with political intrigue is further hindered by a lack of cohesive storytelling, leaving audiences with a sense of disappointment.