The shooting occurred around 3 a.m. on October 18, shortly after Reynolds and another man left Shotgun Willies, a strip club in Denver. They were followed by two vehicles, from which the shots were fired, hitting Reynolds in his left arm and the back of his head. The Denver Police responded to 911 calls and found the victims along with their vehicle, which showed signs of multiple bullet impacts. Two men, identified as Luis Mendoza and Burr Charlesworth, were later arrested and are being held for investigation of attempted first-degree murder and first-degree assault.

Despite the shooting, Reynolds' injuries were reported as minor. He has been placed on injured reserve due to a prior finger injury and has not traveled with the team for recent games. The Broncos have issued a statement acknowledging the incident and deferring further comments to the authorities. Reynolds has been seen doing conditioning work at the team's practice facility, indicating a potential return to the field once fully recovered.

Following the arrests of Mendoza and Charlesworth, the investigation continues as authorities seek to identify any additional suspects involved in the shooting. The legal process is ongoing, with the suspects held on significant bail amounts. The Denver Police have sealed arrest reports and are conducting a thorough investigation to ensure the integrity of the case. This incident has once again highlighted the safety concerns for high-profile athletes in public spaces.