The CMA Awards nomination process does not require submissions from artists or labels; instead, it involves a write-in ballot system used by CMA's voting members. Despite Beyoncé's historic chart-topping on both the country and pop charts with her album and single, her work was notably absent from the nominations. This has raised questions about the criteria and transparency of the CMA's nomination process, especially given the significant achievements of 'Cowboy Carter' within the eligibility period.

The snub has elicited a strong response from various stakeholders. Color of Change, a racial justice nonprofit, criticized the CMA for perpetuating a 'mythical American past' by ignoring Beyoncé's contributions. The organization highlighted the roots of country music in Black culture and the ongoing exclusion of Black excellence from the genre. Fans and other artists have also expressed disappointment, viewing the snub as indicative of broader racial and gender biases in the industry.

Despite the controversy, Beyoncé's 'Cowboy Carter' continues to influence the music industry by blending genres and challenging traditional norms. Her album not only celebrates the contributions of Black artists to country music but also features collaborations with icons like Dolly Parton and Willie Nelson, further bridging the gap between genres. The debate over her CMA Awards snub may foster a larger discussion on inclusivity and recognition in country music, potentially leading to significant changes in how artists are nominated and celebrated.